 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
|
| League History Index | Players | Teams | Managers | Leagues | Leaderboards | Awards | Accomplishments |
| Rank | Player | EFF | YEAR | Open Season Leaderboard |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Mike Piazza# | 1.082 | 1992-1998 | |
| 2 | Mike Lieberthal# | 1.081 | 1994-1998 | |
| 3 | Ivan Rodriguez# | 1.080 | 1991-1998 | |
| 4 | Butch Wynegar | 1.076 | 1976-1987 | |
| 5 | Tony Pena | 1.068 | 1980-1995 | |
| 6 | Todd Zeile# | 1.065 | 1989-1998 | |
| 7 | Johnny Bench | 1.063 | 1976-1983 | |
| 8 | Thurman Munson | 1.062 | 1976-1988 | |
| 9 | Mike Scioscia | 1.059 | 1980-1994 | |
| 10 | Rick Wilkins# | 1.054 | 1991-1998 | |
| 11 | Ted Simmons | 1.051 | 1976-1987 | |
| 12 | Charlie Moore | 1.049 | 1976-1991 | |
| 13 | Joe Oliver# | 1.048 | 1989-1997 | |
| 14 | Brian Harper | 1.045 | 1979-1995 | |
| 15 | Darrell Porter | 1.039 | 1976-1989 | |
| 16 | Terry Steinbach | 1.038 | 1986-1996 | |
| 17 | Benito Santiago# | 1.037 | 1986-1998 | |
| 18 | Nelson Santovenia | 1.033 | 1987-1995 | |
| 19 | Charles Johnson# | 1.031 | 1994-1998 | |
| 19 | Lloyd McClendon | 1.031 | 1987-1993 | |
| 21 | Ron Hassey | 1.029 | 1978-1989 | |
| 22 | Joe Ferguson | 1.028 | 1976-1985 | |
| 22 | Jim Sundberg | 1.028 | 1976-1988 | |
| 22 | John Stearns | 1.028 | 1976-1989 | |
| 25 | Joe Girardi# | 1.027 | 1989-1997 | |
| 25 | Gary Carter | 1.027 | 1976-1989 | |
| 27 | Sandy Alomar Jr.# | 1.026 | 1988-1998 | |
| 28 | Chris Hoiles# | 1.025 | 1989-1998 | |
| 29 | Mike LaValliere# | 1.021 | 1984-1995 | |
| 30 | Lance Parrish | 1.020 | 1977-1993 | |
| 30 | Milt May | 1.020 | 1976-1988 | |
| 32 | Brent Mayne# | 1.013 | 1990-1998 | |
| 33 | Jody Davis | 1.011 | 1981-1992 | |
| 34 | Terry Kennedy | 1.010 | 1978-1992 | |
| 35 | Bob Boone | 1.006 | 1976-1982 | |
| 35 | Tony Eusebio# | 1.006 | 1991-1998 | |
| 37 | Biff Pocoroba | 1.005 | 1976-1984 | |
| 38 | Javy Lopez# | 1.002 | 1992-1998 | |
| 39 | Bob Brenly | 1.001 | 1981-1988 | |
| 39 | Carlton Fisk | 1.001 | 1976-1986 | |
| 41 | Rich Gedman | 1.000 | 1980-1992 | |
| 42 | Alan Ashby | .996 | 1978-1987 | |
| 43 | Bill Haselman# | .993 | 1990-1998 | |
| 44 | Bruce Benedict | .990 | 1978-1989 | |
| 45 | Bo Diaz | .981 | 1978-1991 | |
| 46 | John Ellis | .979 | 1976-1983 | |
| 47 | Don Slaught | .976 | 1982-1993 | |
| 48 | Nobuyuki Kagawa | .973 | 1984-1995 | |
| 49 | John Wockenfuss | .972 | 1976-1988 | |
| 50 | Mike Sweeney# | .969 | 1995-1998 | |
| 51 | Clint Hurdle | .966 | 1977-1990 | |
| 52 | Mickey Tettleton# | .962 | 1985-1997 | |
| 53 | Mike Macfarlane# | .957 | 1987-1996 | |
| 54 | Matt Nokes# | .952 | 1985-1998 | |
| 55 | Dale Murphy* | .947 | 1976-1992 | |
| 55 | Earl Williams | .947 | 1976-1982 | |
| 57 | Mark Bailey | .944 | 1984-1995 | |
| 58 | Cliff Johnson | .940 | 1976-1983 | |
| 59 | Hector Villanueva# | .936 | 1990-1997 | |
| 60 | Dave Engle | .934 | 1981-1989 | |
| 61 | Ron Pruitt | .929 | 1976-1988 | |
| 62 | Darrin Fletcher# | .918 | 1989-1997 | |
| 63 | B.J. Surhoff# | .906 | 1989-1998 | |
| 64 | Geno Petralli | .902 | 1983-1992 | |
| 65 | Mike Stanley# | .875 | 1986-1997 | |
| 66 | Ed Taubensee# | .865 | 1991-1998 |
